How To Have Employees Experience their Manager As A Leader – A Design and Screening Solution
By Michelle Malay Carter on June 10, 2009
My last post?had the word impotent in it twice, so those who read my posts via email may have had the post hijacked by a spam filter.?
Additionally, because my last post was so long, I am?repeating the end of my last post under a new title with one new context setting introductory paragraph.
Managers are managers by virtue of their position.? Employees will experience their managers as leaders when two criteria are met:
- When the manager’s role is located in the next higher work level than the employee.
- When the manager’s cognitive capability falls into the next higher level.
Organizations that understand this can design for leadership and screen for “leadership capability” which is relative to whom is being led.
What Do Employees Want in a Manager?
Paraphrased from Ralph Rowbottom and Davis Billis’, Organisation Design, A Work Levels Approach, when employees encounter knotty problems, employees want a manager who, by virtue of his/her position, has the authority to (this is the requisite organization design part – one role at each work level):
- help by altering the basic context of their work
- alter the whole system in some way
- operate a different set of signals and levers
- make available new types of resources
- initiate new trains of investigation or negotiation
And (here is the individual part which can be screened for), is personally cognitively capable to:
- see the world with a qualitatively different perspective
- overview the whole field of their activity
- provide them with some authoritative assessment of their performance from a higher standpoint
- set them going in new directions and head them off from others
Satisfying Leaders have A Higher Level Role and Matching Cognitive Capability – It’s All Relative to Me
In summary, employees will experience their manager as a leader when both the manager’s role and the manager’s cognitive capability fall into the next level higher than the employee. Organization’s can design and screen for this.
I’m OK. You’re OK. Let’s fix the system.
Is your manager your leader?
Filed Under Employee Engagement, Organization Design, Requisite Organization, Talent Management, Work Levels